Challenges and Opportunities for NICU nursing in California

It’s true: there is a shortage of NICU Nurses in California. From a healthcare staffing agency’s perspective, this is a painful reality. In this article, we are going to address the growing demand and shed light on what’s happening and how we can collectively fix it. Let’s dive right in.

Ready for Hire

NICU Nurses in California: Addressing the Growing Demand

NICU nurses are registered nurses (RNs) who specialize in caring for newborn infants with complex medical conditions, such as prematurity, birth defects, infections, or surgical issues. NICU nurses work in subspecialty NICUs (Levels II, III, and IV) that provide different levels of care depending on the severity and acuity of the infants. NICU nurses are responsible for monitoring, assessing, and treating the infants, as well as educating and supporting the families.

NICU nursing is a rewarding but demanding profession that requires a high level of skill, knowledge, and compassion. NICU nurses must be able to handle stressful and emotional situations, work in a fast-paced and dynamic environment, and collaborate with a multidisciplinary team of neonatologists, nurse practitioners, respiratory therapists, pharmacists, social workers, and others. NICU nurses also need to keep up with the latest evidence-based practices and technologies in neonatal care.

The State of NICU Nursing in California

California is one of the most populous and diverse states in the US, with nearly half a million babies born every year, representing one in eight of all births in the country1. While the number of births has declined since 2000, childbirth remains the number one reason for hospitalization in California1. According to the California Perinatal Quality Care Collaborative (CPQCC):

• there are 165 NICUs in California, with a total of 3,720 NICU beds
• Of these, 24 are regional NICUs (Level IV), 83 are community NICUs (Level III)
• 15 are intermediate NICUs (Level II), and 28 are non-CCS NICUs (Level I or II).

The demand for NICU nurses in California is driven by several factors, such as the increasing number of high-risk pregnancies, multiple births, and preterm births; the rising prevalence of maternal and neonatal complications, such as diabetes, hypertension, and infections; the expanding scope and complexity of neonatal care, such as hypothermia therapy, extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO), and nitric oxide therapy; and the growing awareness and expectations of families and consumers regarding quality and safety of care.

According to the National Certification Corporation (NCC), there are 668 neonatologists and 88 neonatal nurse practitioners in California, as of 2021. However, the number of NICU nurses that are certified in California is not readily available, as there is no mandatory requirement or standardized process for obtaining or reporting certification. The NCC offers two voluntary certification exams for NICU nurses: the Neonatal Intensive Care Nursing (RNC-NIC) exam and the Low Risk Neonatal Nursing (RNC-LRN) exam.

According to the NCC, there are 34,307 NICU nurses and 7,752 low risk neonatal nurses certified in the US, as of 2021. Assuming that California has a proportional share of these certified nurses based on its population, we can estimate that there are about 4,100 NICU nurses and 930 low risk neonatal nurses certified in California. However, this is likely an underestimate, as California has a higher percentage of NICU beds and admissions than the national average.

The supply of NICU nurses in California is influenced by several factors, such as the availability and quality of nursing education and training programs, the recruitment and retention strategies of employers, the satisfaction and well-being of nurses, the regulation and reimbursement policies of the state, and the demographic and geographic characteristics of the workforce. According to ZipRecruiter, the average weekly pay for a NICU nurse in California is $2,238, as of 2024. This is higher than the national average of $1,731, but lower than some other states, such as New York, Massachusetts, and Hawaii. The pay for NICU nurses may also vary by region, experience, education, certification, and employer within California.

The Challenges and Opportunities for NICU Nursing in California

One of the major challenges facing NICU nursing in California is the issue of staffing. Appropriate staffing is essential for delivering safe and effective care to NICU patients, who are vulnerable infants that are wholly dependent on their caregivers. A sufficient number and appropriate mix of qualified RNs are needed in subspecialty NICUs to meet the needs of the infants and their families. However, evidence suggests that understaffing is a significant problem in many NICUs, which puts patients at increased risk of missed or rationed care, medical errors, disparities of care, and morbidity and mortality.

Staffing in the NICU is determined by a complex interplay of factors, such as the acuity and intensity of the infants, the education and experience of the nurses, the preferences and availability of the nurses, the structure and layout of the unit, the shift length and schedule, the care model and delivery system, and the organizational culture and climate. Staffing is also affected by the variability and unpredictability of the NICU environment, such as the fluctuations in census and admissions, the changes in patient conditions and interventions, the interruptions and distractions, and the emergencies and transfers3.

There is no consensus or standard on the optimal staffing ratio or method for the NICU, as different studies and guidelines have suggested different approaches and recommendations based on different assumptions and outcomes. However, some general principles and best practices have been proposed by various professional organizations and experts, such as the National Association of Neonatal Nurses (NANN), the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), the Association of Women’s Health, Obstetric and Neonatal Nurses (AWHONN), and the California Children’s Services (CCS)37. These include:

• Staffing should be based on the acuity and intensity of the infants, not just the number or level of the beds.
• Staffing should be flexible and responsive to the changing needs and situations of the infants and the unit.
• Staffing should be supported by adequate resources and infrastructure, such as equipment, supplies, space, and technology.
• Staffing should be guided by evidence-based practices and quality improvement initiatives, such as benchmarking, auditing, and feedback.
• Staffing should be transparent and collaborative, involving the input and participation of the nurses, managers, physicians, and other stakeholders.
• Staffing should be fair and equitable, respecting the rights and preferences of the nurses, as well as the diversity and needs of the patients and families.

Another major challenge facing NICU nursing in California is the issue of quality. Quality of care is the degree to which health services for individuals and populations increase the likelihood of desired health outcomes and are consistent with current professional knowledge3. Quality of care is a multidimensional concept that encompasses various aspects, such as safety, effectiveness, efficiency, timeliness, patient-centeredness, and equity3. Quality of care is also a dynamic process that requires continuous monitoring, evaluation, and improvement3.

Quality of care in the NICU is influenced by several factors, such as the characteristics and outcomes of the infants, the competencies and practices of the nurses, the policies and protocols of the unit, the collaboration and communication of the team, the engagement and satisfaction of the families, and the performance and accountability of the system3. Quality of care in the NICU is also affected by the challenges and opportunities of the NICU environment, such as the complexity and uncertainty of neonatal care, the innovation and advancement of neonatal science, the diversity and disparity of neonatal populations, and the advocacy and empowerment of neonatal stakeholders3.

There are various indicators and measures that can be used to assess and improve the quality of care in the NICU, such as the process, structure, and outcome indicators3. Some examples of these indicators are:

• Process indicators: the adherence to evidence-based guidelines and standards, such as the use of antenatal steroids, the administration of surfactant, the initiation of breastfeeding, and the prevention of infections.
• Structure indicators: the availability and adequacy of resources and infrastructure, such as the number and qualification of staff, the equipment and supplies, the space and layout, and the technology and information systems.
• Outcome indicators: the results and consequences of care, such as the mortality and morbidity rates, the length of stay and readmission rates, the growth and development outcomes, and the patient and family satisfaction and experience.

There are various sources and methods that can be used to collect and analyze the data for these indicators, such as the clinical records and charts, the administrative and billing data, the surveys and questionnaires, the audits and observations, and the registries and databases3. Some examples of these sources and methods are:

• Clinical records and charts: the documentation of the patient’s history, physical examination, diagnosis, treatment, and progress, such as the admission and discharge summaries, the progress notes, the medication orders, and the vital signs.
• Administrative and billing data: the information related to the patient’s demographics, insurance, and utilization of services, such as the length of stay, the charges, and the diagnosis-related groups.
• Surveys and questionnaires: the feedback from the patients, families, and staff regarding their perceptions, experiences, and satisfaction with the care, such as the Family-Centered Care Survey, the Nurse Work Environment Survey, and the Patient Safety Culture Survey.
• Audits and observations: the assessment of the compliance and performance of the care processes and practices, such as the hand hygiene audits, the medication administration audits, and the direct observation of care.
• Registries and databases: the collection and analysis of the standardized data on the patient outcomes and quality measures, such as the Vermont Oxford Network, the California Perinatal Quality Care Collaborative, and the National Healthcare Safety Network.

These sources and methods can provide valuable information for monitoring and improving the quality of care in the NICU, but they also have some limitations and challenges, such as the validity and reliability of the data, the feasibility and cost of the data collection, the comparability and benchmarking of the data, and the interpretation and dissemination of the data.

The Future of NICU Nursing in California

NICU nursing in California faces many challenges, but also many opportunities for improvement and innovation. As a healthcare staffing agency and a management consulting business, Health2Talent is dedicated to supporting and enhancing the NICU nursing workforce in California, by providing the following services and solutions:

• Recruitment and placement: We help our clients find and hire qualified and competent NICU nurses, by using our extensive network and database, our rigorous screening and selection process, and our customized matching and orientation system.
• Education and training: We help our clients develop and deliver effective and efficient education and training programs for NICU nurses, by using our evidence-based curriculum and methods, our experienced and certified instructors and mentors, and our state-of-the-art technology and simulation tools.
• Evaluation and improvement: We help our clients measure and improve the quality and performance of NICU nurses, by using our comprehensive and reliable indicators and measures, our advanced and user-friendly data analysis and visualization software, and our collaborative and participatory quality improvement initiatives.

We believe that NICU nurses are a vital profession that deserves recognition and support, and that NICU nursing is a rewarding and fulfilling career that offers many opportunities for growth and development. We invite you to contact us today to learn more about our services and solutions, and how we can help you achieve your goals and vision for NICU nursing in California.